My Cookie Lady—Handmade Sweets

Order information and pricing

 

 

 

Due to the delicate nature of some of the cookies on the tray, shipped cookies may be packed differently than delivered cookies.

We work to pack cookies so that they can be delivered without breakage but can not guarantee shipped cookies will arrive as perfectly as we packed them.  We will guarantee that they are delicious!!

All products are made in kitchens that produce products that  may contain peanuts, tree nuts or traces of peanuts and tree nuts.

All products contain wheat and egg products unless otherwise noted.

Text Box: We Ship anywhere!
Mix any 6 containers of our classic cookies -$40.00 INCLUDES SHIPPING

Sweet Gathering dessert presentation – $4.50 per person (Minimum 80 people)
We provide a buffet assortment of your choice of sweets at your banquet hall, restaurant or in your home

Delivery Details -

We  ship cookies via USPS or UPS for an additional charge of  $8.

We will deliver in the Chicago land area for an additional charge of $5.

For orders requiring shipment, please place your order 5 days prior to the day you would like the cookies to arrive.

48 hour lead time is needed for local delivery. 

Try  our Individually wrapped treats—Just $2.00 per package.  Or 3 for $5.00

Choose from:

Oatmeal Carmelita Bars                                       Seven Layer Bars

Chewy Chocolate Chip (2 pack)                           Chocolate Drumsticks

Rockin Raspberry Bars                                         Syl’s Sugar Cookies (2 pack)

Ginger Snaps (2 pack)                                          Oatmeal Raisin Cookie (2 pack)

 

We bake cookies from fresh and natural ingredients.  

We package and ship them to you fresh and delicious.

Specialty Cookies—packed in clear container  (avg wt  6-10oz)          

Price

Pecan Tassies—8 pieces per package

 Buttery Crust filled with pecans and caramel filling.

$7.00

Glump Cookies –8 pieces per package

White Chocolate and peanut butter with rice krispies, dry roasted peanuts and marshmallows

$7.00

Oatmeal Carmelitas—8 pieces per package

Oatmeal crust layered with caramel and semi sweet chocolate

$7.00

Seven Layer Bars—8 pieces per package

Graham cracker crust layered with butterscotch and chocolate chips topped with coconut and sweetened milk.

$7.00

Teacake Snowballs – 10 pieces per package

Buttery dough filled with finely chopped nuts and then coated with layers of powdered sugar

$7.00

Sunshine Lemon Cookies – 6 per package

Tasty fresh lemon zest and juice are used through all layers of this cookie.   A true bite of sunshine!

$7.00

Almond Toffee—1/2 pd per package

A buttery and delicious toffee filled with almonds and topped with milk chocolate and more almonds.

$7.00

Brownie Bites 8 pieces per package

Mini brownies topped with deep chocolate icing and a colorful candy

$7.00

Kolachkys 9 pieces er package

 Pastry topped with Cherry, Raspberry and Apricot filling.  Dusted with a coating of powdered sugar.

$7.00

Banket 8 oz pastry

Our traditional Dutch pastry filled with almond paste and baked to buttery perfection.

$7.00

Mini Chip Bon Bons   10 pieces per package

Buttery dough filled with mini chocolate chips and topped with a swirl of chocolate

 

$7.00

 

 

Chocolate Drumsticks5 pieces per package

Pretzel rod coated with caramel, rolled in nuts and dipped in milk chocolate.

$7.00

Gluten Free Items

 

Gluten Free Banana Bread—We make these mini sweet and moist breads by hand. 

There are several varieties to choose from including traditional, chocolate chip, and walnut.  Each package has 1/2 mini loaf sliced into 4 pieces.  (Full loaves available upon request)

$4.00

Gluten Free Cookies—We took our traditional recipes and customized them for Gluten Free versions.  Only you will know that these are gluten free varieties!  Each container holds 6 pieces.

Choose from:

Chocolate Chip

Oatmeal Raisin

Lemon Sugar Cookies

$5.00

Other Goodies

 

Caramel Corn—10 oz bag

We pop the corn by hand then pour our handmade caramel over and mix it in to coat every kernel  Then we bake this tasty treat in a slow oven for more than an hour.  The result is a crunchy, sweet and buttery delicious treat.

$4.00

My Sisters Granola— 8oz container

We use all of the freshest ingrediants for our granola.  Whole Oats mixed with lots of pecans and almonds sweetened with honey and slow baked to crunchy goodness.  Perfect with yogurt or as a yummy snack. 

$7.00

Cinnamon Rolls—Sold in Eaches

Each roll is hand made from scratch.  Filled with buttery cinnamon filling and topped with our yummy icing 

$2.00

Pecan Rolls—Sold in Eaches

We make our pecan rolls from scratch with the finest ingrediants.  Our caramel coating and fresh pecans will make your mouth water just looking at these beauties. 

$3.50

Classic Cookies—packed with 6 cookies per clear container  (avg wt 8-10oz)    $6.00

Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies

Gourmet chocolate chip cookies always soft, chewy and delicious.

 

Ginger Snap Cookies   Our Great Grandmas recipe.

She had these tasty treats ready when Threshers came to the farm to work in the fields.  A big hit then and even better now.

Peanut Butter cup Cookies

 Our old fashioned  Peanut butter cookie recipe topped with a peanut butter cup.

 

Syl’s Sugar Cookies

Our melt in your mouth version of this old favorite.  We roll each cookie by hand in vanilla sugar for a melt in your mouth old fashioned goodness.

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies

Buttery cookies filled with oatmeal, sweet raisins and crunchy pecans baked to crisp and chewy goodness